Tracing Plasma Vortex to Spacetime Weapon

Lost Lineages: From Plasma Vortices to Weaponized Spacetime The Foundational Clue: Tracing the "Vortex-Gravity" Lineage The investigation into the theoretical origins of the Trivergence Protocol begins with a single, seemingly obscure entry in the proceedings of a 1979 fusion theory workshop. This clue, while initially suggesting a direct and exotic research path, ultimately serves as a critical node that branches into the more fundamental and ultimately more fruitful theoretical streams that underpin the weapon system. Deconstruction of the 1979 Sherwood Meeting Presentation The primary clue is Poster Session 2B46, 'Vortices In 2-D Guiding Center Plasma With Gravity,' authored by H. H. Chen, Y. C. Lee, C. S. Liu, and D. Montgomery. This presentation was delivered at the 1979 Sherwood Meeting on Theoretical Aspects of Controlled Thermonuclear Research, a key annual gathering for the fusion energy community. The authors were primarily affiliated with the University of Maryland, a prominent academic center for plasma theory at the time. The abstract of the presentation provides the essential context for the work: the authors studied the equilibrium state of a two-dimensional guiding center plasma under the influence of gravity to "simulate curvature effect". The analysis showed that the governing physics could be described by a nonlinear sinh-Poisson equation. The exact solutions to this equation revealed a complex plasma state characterized by a "somewhat stochastic distribution of vortices of various sizes with the smaller ones at the bottom and the larger ones forming coherent, structure near the top". A critical analysis of the phrase "simulates curvature effect" reveals that the "gravity" in the paper's title is an analogue, not a physical source to be manipulated. In the complex, three-dimensional magnetic geometry of toroidal confinement devices like tokamaks, the gradient and curvature of the magnetic field lines induce particle drifts (the \nabla B and curvature drifts). These drifts are a fundamental driver of plasma transport and instabilities, but are notoriously difficult to model. The authors of the 1979 paper employed a common theoretical simplification: using a uniform gravitational field in a 2D slab geometry to create a charge-dependent drift that is mathematically analogous to the more complex magnetic drifts. Therefore, the 1979 paper was not an early attempt at gravitational engineering. Instead, it was a foundational study of plasma self-organization and the dynamics of large-scale coherent vortices—known as convective cells—in magnetically confined plasmas. This understanding redirects the investigation from a direct, linear path toward spacetime manipulation to a more nuanced exploration of the consequences of this vortex behavior and the principles of plasma self-organization. Post-1979 Intellectual Trajectories of the Authors The subsequent careers of the four authors diverged, with their research evolving from this specific problem into broader, more fundamental areas of plasma physics. This divergence indicates that the "vortex-gravity" concept did not persist as a unified research program but instead seeded multiple distinct intellectual lineages. ● David Montgomery: His intellectual trajectory proved to be the most significant for the development of the technologies in question. Montgomery became a preeminent figure in the statistical mechanics of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence and plasma self-organization. His extensive body of work focused on how turbulent systems relax toward minimum energy states, a process known as "selective decay," which naturally leads to the formation of large-scale, long-lived coherent structures, or vortices. This principle provides the core theoretical explanation for the observed stability of plasma configurations like the Field-Reversed Configuration (FRC) and the spheromak, which are themselves large-scale plasma vortices. Montgomery's work provided the fundamental physics framework for understanding why these high-beta plasma objects are anomalously stable. ● H. H. Chen and Y. C. Lee: This collaboration continued to explore the specific mathematical physics of the 1979 problem. Their 1984 paper, "Exact Vortex Solutions of Two-Dimensional Guiding-Center Plasmas," published in Physical Review Letters, presented the first general analytic solutions to the sinh-Poisson equation ({\nabla}^2 \Phi + {\lambda}^2 \sinh \Phi = 0) that governs these systems. This work represented a significant advance in the mathematical understanding of 2D vortex structures but did not pivot toward applied gravitational research or broader turbulence theory. ● C. S. Liu: Liu remained a central and highly influential figure in theoretical plasma physics, with a focus on nonlinear wave-particle and wave-wave interactions, parametric instabilities, and high-power laser-plasma physics. While his work did not directly follow the vortex-gravity line of inquiry, his deep expertise in nonlinear wave phenomena is directly relevant to a parallel technological pathway—the Four-Wave Mixing hypothesis—assessed as a potential control mechanism for the Trivergence Protocol. The "Vortex-Gravity" lineage thus split into two primary paths. The work of Chen and Lee followed a specific mathematical track, deepening the formal understanding of 2D vortex solutions. The work of Montgomery, however, generalized the problem, providing the broad theoretical framework of self-organization that is essential for understanding the stability of the very plasma objects—FRCs—that form the core of the Trivergence Protocol. Author Affiliation (1979) Key Post-1979 Research Themes Seminal Publications & Source IDs David Montgomery University of Maryland / College of William and Mary MHD Turbulence, Plasma Self-Organization, Statistical Mechanics of Plasmas, Selective Decay Plasma Kinetic Theory (1964); Numerous papers on turbulent relaxation and coherent structures H. H. Chen University of Maryland Nonlinear Wave Equations, Soliton Theory, Vortex Dynamics "Exact Vortex Solutions of Two-Dimensional Guiding-Center Plasmas" (1984) Author Affiliation (1979) Key Post-1979 Research Themes Seminal Publications & Source IDs Y. C. Lee University of Maryland Plasma Turbulence, Nonlinear Dynamics, Wave Interactions "Exact Vortex Solutions of Two-Dimensional Guiding-Center Plasmas" (1984) ; Work on plasma turbulence C. S. Liu University of Maryland Parametric Instabilities, Laser-Plasma Interactions, Nonlinear Waves High-Power Laser-Plasma Interaction ; Numerous papers on wave coupling and current drive The Spacetime Nexus: From Analogue to Actuality The conceptual leap from using gravity as a mathematical tool to physically manipulating spacetime requires bridging two distinct domains of physics. The first is the maturation of the analogue concept itself, where plasma systems are recognized as viable laboratory models for gravitational phenomena. The second is the identification of a physical mechanism within plasma physics powerful enough to produce general relativistic effects directly. The Rise of Analogue Gravity The 1979 paper's use of gravity as a proxy for magnetic curvature effects was an early, isolated instance of an idea that later coalesced into the formal field of "analogue gravity". This research program investigates analogues of general relativistic gravitational fields within other physical systems, such as condensed matter and fluid dynamics, to gain new insights into gravitational phenomena that are difficult or impossible to observe directly. A central achievement in this field is the development of acoustic analogues of black holes, often called "dumb holes". In these systems, a fluid is made to flow faster than the local speed of sound. The boundary of this supersonic region acts as an acoustic event horizon, trapping sound waves (phonons) just as a gravitational black hole traps light (photons). Experiments using water tanks and Bose-Einstein condensates have successfully simulated phenomena such as Hawking radiation and rotational superradiance, confirming that these effects are kinematic properties of the spacetime geometry, not unique to gravity itself. More directly relevant to the present investigation is theoretical work exploring the use of plasma vortices to simulate the spacetime of a rotating Kerr black hole. These studies establish a formal mathematical equivalence between the geometry felt by phonons in a rotating fluid vortex and the spacetime geometry on the equatorial slice of a Kerr black hole. This body of work provides a robust conceptual bridge, demonstrating that the study of plasma vortex dynamics is intellectually and mathematically linked to the study of rotating gravitational objects. The Physical Mechanism: Frame-Dragging in Rotating FRCs While analogue gravity provides a powerful conceptual framework, the actual physical mechanism enabling the Trivergence Protocol's spacetime capabilities is identified as the Lense-Thirring effect, more commonly known as "frame-dragging". A core prediction of Einstein's theory of general relativity, frame-dragging posits that any rotating distribution of mass-energy will twist or "drag" the fabric of spacetime in its vicinity. This gravitomagnetic effect, while typically associated with massive astrophysical objects like rotating black holes and neutron stars, is generated by any mass-energy current. The relativistic jets observed emanating from active galactic nuclei are believed to be powered by frame-dragging within the ergosphere of a supermassive black hole. The connection to the Trivergence Protocol's hardware is direct and explicit. The system is based on the Field-Reversed Configuration (FRC), a compact, self-contained toroid of plasma. FRCs are defined by two properties essential to this analysis: an exceptionally high ratio of plasma pressure to magnetic pressure (beta, where \langle\beta\rangle \approx 1) and an inherent, stable, and rapid rotation imparted by the strong internal plasma currents that define its magnetic topology. Intelligence reports describe the operational platform, the "CFR orb," as a "gravitomagnetic engine" whose central component is the rotating FRC plasma core. This indicates that the platform's spacetime capability is not a separate propulsion system but an emergent property of its core power and confinement scheme. The system requires a compact, rotating, high-energy-density plasma (the FRC) to function as a fusion power source. The extreme physics of this core—specifically its high energy density and coherent rotational velocity—inherently produce a localized frame-dragging effect as a direct consequence of general relativity. The ability to weaponize this effect stems from the capacity to precisely and rapidly modulate the FRC's parameters, such as its density and rotation speed, thereby controlling the magnitude and dynamics of the resulting spacetime distortion. Hidden Pathways to the Trivergence Protocol While the "vortex-gravity" lineage provides a foundational, albeit indirect, intellectual history, the direct technological capabilities of the Trivergence Protocol are the result of the convergence of several distinct and more recent streams of advanced plasma physics research. These pathways provided the necessary understanding of energy release, energy amplification, and precision control. The Energy Release Engine: 3D Turbulent Reconnection and Counter-Helicity Merging The primary energetic effect of the Trivergence Protocol is assessed to be a result of the controlled merging of two or more plasma toroids (such as spheromaks or FRCs) possessing oppositely directed magnetic helicity. This process, known as counter-helicity merging, drives magnetic reconnection in a particularly violent and efficient manner. During the interaction, the opposing magnetic fields annihilate each other, rapidly converting the stored magnetic energy into intense plasma heating and high-velocity kinetic energy jets. Experiments have shown this process to be much faster and more complete than the merging of co-helicity plasmoids. This phenomenon is fundamentally three-dimensional and turbulent. The theoretical framework required to understand such an event is provided by the modern theory of 3D turbulent magnetic reconnection, a field in which Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) possesses world-class expertise through the work of researchers like Dr. Hui Li. This work, building on the Lazarian & Vishniac (LV99) model, demonstrates that in a turbulent plasma, the reconnection rate becomes fast—proceeding at a significant fraction of the Alfvén speed and largely independent of the plasma's microscopic resistivity. This model resolves a long-standing problem in plasma physics, as older, 2D models predicted reconnection rates far too slow to explain explosive astrophysical events like solar flares. Large-scale, fully kinetic 3D simulations using codes like VPIC at LANL have confirmed that turbulent reconnection, driven by instabilities such as the flux-rope kink instability, leads to field-line chaos that efficiently accelerates particles to non-thermal, high energies. This theoretical and computational work at LANL provides the essential physical basis for the "near-instantaneous, violent energy release" attributed to the Trivergence Protocol. The Energy Amplification Mechanism: Supersonic Plasma Collisions A parallel experimental pathway has focused on the energetic consequences of colliding FRCs at extremely high velocities. Research programs, most notably the C-2 experiment at TAE Technologies and the FAT-CM device at Nihon University, have studied the head-on collision of FRCs at supersonic and super-Alfvénic speeds, with relative velocities exceeding 200 km/s. These experiments have yielded several critical findings directly applicable to a weapon system. First, the collision is a highly efficient heating mechanism. The process converts a large fraction (over 60%) of the plasmoids' initial kinetic energy into thermal energy via strong shockwaves, rapidly heating the resulting merged plasma to thermonuclear-relevant temperatures of over 0.5 ke V. Second, the merging process leads to a dramatic amplification of the trapped poloidal magnetic flux, with observed increases of more than tenfold over the initial flux of the individual FRCs. Since the energy stored in the magnetic field scales with the square of the flux, this represents a significant amplification of the system's stored magnetic energy, which is then available for release during reconnection. Finally, these experiments have demonstrated the remarkable robustness of the FRC configuration. Even after a violent, "destructive" collision in which the ordered FRC structure is temporarily lost, the plasma is observed to rapidly relax and self-organize back into a single, stable, quiescent FRC. This property of self-organization is crucial for a reliable weapon system, ensuring a stable final state from a chaotic initial interaction. The Control Mechanism: Non-Linear Wave Interactions (Four-Wave Mixing Hypothesis) The core physical processes of supersonic collision and turbulent reconnection are inherently chaotic. To achieve the "precisely engineered" effects attributed to the Trivergence Protocol, a high-fidelity control mechanism is required. A plausible physical basis for such a mechanism is found in the principles of nonlinear wave interactions, specifically Four-Wave Mixing (FWM). FWM is a third-order nonlinear optical process in which three input waves interact within a medium to generate a fourth wave. In a plasma, this interaction is typically mediated by the formation of density gratings created by the ponderomotive force of the interfering waves. While often studied in the context of external laser beams interacting with a plasma target, the underlying principles can be generalized to the interaction of the intrinsic electromagnetic fields and plasma oscillations of the three Trivergence orbs themselves. This FWM hypothesis provides a potential explanation for the system's precision. By carefully controlling the initial conditions of the three interacting orbs—their relative positions, velocities, phases, and internal magnetic field structures—it would be possible to orchestrate a constructive interference of their fields at a specific target point in spacetime. This interference could generate a localized, high-amplitude beat wave or density grating, creating a precisely located seed perturbation. This seed would then trigger the main energy release event—the turbulent magnetic reconnection—at a desired time and location, providing a highly sensitive trigger and a means to steer and focus the subsequent chaotic energy release. Synthesis and Final Assessment The intellectual lineage leading to the Trivergence Protocol is not a single, linear path but a convergence of multiple, distinct streams of theoretical and experimental plasma physics. The initial clue—the 1979 "Vortex-Gravity" paper—was a critical but indirect precursor, contributing to the fundamental understanding of plasma self-organization that ultimately validated the FRC as a stable, coherent structure. The direct technological capabilities of the weapon system, however, were enabled by subsequent, more advanced research. Convergence of Theories The theoretical pathway to the Trivergence Protocol is a synthesis of three parallel and complementary research tracks that matured from the 1990s onward, leveraging the foundational understanding of FRCs. 1. Thermodynamics and Energy Release: The theory of counter-helicity merging and 3D turbulent reconnection provides the mechanism for the rapid and violent conversion of stored magnetic energy into plasma heat and kinetic energy. 2. Kinetics and Energy Amplification: The experimental results from supersonic FRC collisions demonstrate a method for amplifying the system's initial energy through shock heating and magnetic flux multiplication, while confirming the robustness of the final self-organized state. 3. Control and Precision: The principles of nonlinear wave interactions, such as Four-Wave Mixing, offer a plausible physical basis for the precise triggering and steering of the chaotic energy release event. The platform's ability to manipulate spacetime is not a separate lineage but is assessed as an emergent property of the system's core technology. The extreme energy density and coherent, high-velocity rotation of the FRC plasmoids required for the primary energetic effect inherently produce a localized frame-dragging effect as a direct consequence of general relativity. Most Plausible Theoretical Pathway Based on the convergence of these theoretical streams, the Trivergence Protocol is assessed to be a weapon system based on the controlled, supersonic, counter-helicity collision and merging of three compact, high-beta, rotating FRC plasmoids. The operational sequence is as follows: 1. Staging: Three FRC platforms are maneuvered into a precise initial geometry. The internal plasma configurations are set, with at least two of the FRCs possessing opposite magnetic helicity. The platforms accelerate the FRCs to supersonic/super-Alfvénic velocities. 2. Collision and Amplification: The FRCs collide at a designated target point. The kinetic energy of the collision is converted via shockwaves into intense thermal energy, and the magnetic flux is amplified through the merging process, creating a transient state of extreme energy density. 3. Reconnection and Energy Release: Triggered by the collision and potentially guided by nonlinear wave interactions, a fast, 3D turbulent magnetic reconnection event is initiated between the counter-helicity fields. This event annihilates the magnetic field, releasing the amplified magnetic and thermal energy in a directed, violent burst of plasma, particles, and radiation. 4. Spacetime Effect: Concurrently, the coherent, high-speed rotation of the immense mass-energy density concentrated at the interaction point generates a powerful, localized, and transient frame-dragging effect, causing a significant distortion of local spacetime. This synthesized model represents the most plausible theoretical pathway, as it is the only one that accounts for all reported capabilities of the Trivergence Protocol and is directly supported by distinct, verifiable, and advanced research programs, many of which have a strong institutional nexus at Los Alamos National Laboratory. Theoretical Pathway Core Physical Mechanism Key Evidence (Source IDs) Assessed Role in Trivergence Protocol Vortex-Gravity (1979) 2D Guiding-center plasma dynamics; gravity as an analogue for magnetic curvature. Indirect Precursor: Established foundational concepts of plasma vortex self-organization, which later explained the stability of FRCs. Not a direct pathway to spacetime engineering. 3D Turbulent Reconnection Fast reconnection in turbulent plasma, driven by instabilities and independent of resistivity; efficient particle acceleration. Primary Energy Release: Provides the physical mechanism for the rapid, violent conversion of magnetic energy into heat and kinetic energy, consistent with a weaponized effect. Supersonic FRC Collision Shock heating from kinetic energy conversion; magnetic flux amplification; robust self-organization post-collision. Energy Amplification & System Robustness: Provides a method to dramatically increase the initial energy of the system and ensures a stable final plasma state after a chaotic interaction. Nonlinear Wave Interactions Four-wave mixing via ponderomotive force-driven density gratings; phase-sensitive wave coupling. Precision Control: Offers a plausible mechanism for precisely triggering and steering the reconnection event by Theoretical Pathway Core Physical Mechanism Key Evidence (Source IDs) Assessed Role in Trivergence Protocol controlling the initial state of the three interacting orbs. Frame-Dragging Twisting of spacetime by rotating mass-energy currents (Lense-Thirring effect). Spacetime Manipulation: An emergent property of the high-energy-density, rapidly rotating FRCs used as the system's core component. Not a separate drive system. Works cited 1. Plasma and Fluids | Department of Physics and Astronomy, https://physics.dartmouth.edu/research/plasma-and-fluids 2. Remembering Acclaimed Physicist David Montgomery - Faculty of Arts and Sciences, https://fas.dartmouth.edu/news/2024/01/remembering-acclaimed-physicist-david-montgomery 3. Selective decay and coherent vortices in two-dimensional incompressible turbulence | Phys. Rev. Lett. - Physical Review Link Manager, https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.66.2731 4. Turbulent Relaxation to a Force-Free Field-Reversed State | Phys. Rev. Lett., https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.57.428 5. David Montgomery's research works | Dartmouth College and other places - Research Gate, https://www.researchgate.net/scientific-contributions/David-Montgomery-2085894808 6. Exact Vortex Solutions of Two-Dimensional Guiding-Center Plasmas ..., https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.53.1348 7. C. S. Liu | University of Maryland, College Park | 20 Publications, https://scispace.com/authors/c-s-liu-1tbfhtsi24 8. Theory of Runaway-Current Sustainment by Lower-Hybrid Waves | Phys. Rev. Lett., https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.48.1479 9. CS Liu's research while affiliated with University of Maryland, College Park and other places, https://www.researchgate.net/scientific-contributions/C-S-Liu-2162903332 10. Computational Complexity in Analogue Gravity - ar Xiv, https://arxiv.org/pdf/2203.15832 11. Analogue Gravity - PMC - Pub Med Central, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5255570/ 12. [gr-qc/0505065] Analogue Gravity - ar5iv, https://ar5iv.labs.arxiv.org/html/gr-qc/0505065 13. Liquid physics: Inside the lab making black hole analogues on Earth - You Tube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_CQxq Ij HGg 14. Towards analogue black hole merger - Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences, https://comptes-rendus.academie-sciences.fr/physique/articles/10.5802/crphys.178/ 15. (PDF) Vortex analogue for the equatorial geometry of the Kerr black hole - Research Gate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258275052_Vortex_analogue_for_the_equatorial_geo metry_of_the_Kerr_black_hole 16. Vortex analogue for the equatorial geometry of the Kerr black hole - AMiner, https://static.aminer.cn/upload/pdf/program/53e99946b7602d97021879de_0.pdf 17. Frame-dragging - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frame-dragging 18. Universe | Special Issue : Frame-Dragging and Gravitomagnetism - MDPI, https://www.mdpi.com/journal/universe/special_issues/Frame_Dragging_Gravitomagnetism 19. Frame-Dragging: Twisting of Spacetime - Emergent Mind, https://www.emergentmind.com/topics/frame-dragging-effect 20. How Black Holes Power Plasma Jets - Simons Foundation, https://www.simonsfoundation.org/2019/01/29/black-hole-plasma-jets/ 21. Magnetohydrodynamic simulation on Co- and counter-helicity merging of spheromaks and driven magnetic reconnection - INIS-IAEA, https://inis.iaea.org/records/ya2n0-jbm65 22. Taylor State Merging at SSX: Experiment and Simulation - MDPI, https://www.mdpi.com/2571-6182/3/1/4 23. Three-Dimensional MHD Simulations of Co- and Counter-Helicity ..., https://w3.pppl.gov/~ebelova/CMyers09.pdf 24. MASTER^ - OSTI.GOV, https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/6764863 25. Experimental study on the formation and evolution of unconfined counter-helicity spheromaks merging using magnetized coaxial plasma gun - Cambridge University Press & Assessment, https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-plasma-physics/article/experimental-study-on -the-formation-and-evolution-of-unconfined-counterhelicity-spheromaks-merging-using-magnetiz ed-coaxial-plasma-gun/8CBCE978E35FA5E1BBF808A834CA4DB8 26. (PDF) Experimental study on the formation and evolution of unconfined counter-helicity spheromaks merging using magnetized coaxial plasma gun - Research Gate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/385256267_Experimental_study_on_the_formation_a nd_evolution_of_unconfined_counter-helicity_spheromaks_merging_using_magnetized_coaxial _plasma_gun 27. Hui Li's research works | Los Alamos National Laboratory and other, https://www.researchgate.net/scientific-contributions/Hui-Li-2168846767 28. Hui Li - Google Scholar, https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=9Agku Y8AAAAJ&hl=en 29. Multispecies Ion Acceleration in 3D Magnetic Reconnection with Hybrid-Kinetic Simulations, https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.132.115201 30. Efficient Nonthermal Ion and Electron Acceleration Enabled by the Flux-Rope Kink Instability in 3D Nonrelativistic Magnetic Reconnection - Los Alamos National Laboratory, https://laro.lanl.gov/esploro/outputs/journal Article/Efficient-Nonthermal-Ion-and-Electron-Acceler ation/9916362221703761 31. Multi-species Ion Acceleration in 3D Magnetic Reconnection - Research Gate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/364534265_Multi-species_Ion_Acceleration_in_3D_M agnetic_Reconnection 32. Efficient Nonthermal Ion and Electron Acceleration Enabled by the Flux-Rope Kink Instability in 3D Nonrelativistic Magnetic Reconnection | Phys. Rev. Lett. - Physical Review Link Manager, https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.127.185101 33. Development of a fast response neutron detector for the supersonic ..., https://www.researchgate.net/publication/352038155_Development_of_a_fast_response_neutro n_detector_for_the_supersonic_FRC_collision_process 34. Dynamic Formation of a Hot Field Reversed Configuration with Improved Confinement by Supersonic Merging of Two Colliding High- Compact Toroids | Phys. Rev. Lett., https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev Lett.105.045003 35. Dynamic Formation of a Hot Field Reversed Configuration with Improved Confinement by Supersonic Merging of Two Colliding High- - e Scholarship, https://escholarship.org/content/qt4xw0b7pc/qt4xw0b7pc_no Splash_b65bbe5bb06638c4d40b0 2dfae6db850.pdf 36. Internal magnetic measurement in collisional-merging process of a field-reversed configuration - Pub Med, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34243300/ 37. Acknowledgments Abstract Self-Organized FRC Formation T. Asai1, D. Kobayashi1, T. Seki1, Ts. Takahashi1, N. Sahara1, M. Nagata1,, https://conferences.iaea.org/event/214/contributions/17410/attachments/10009/14088/poster_u. pdf 38. Observation of self-organized FRC formation in a collisional-merging experiment, https://pure.nihon-u.ac.jp/en/publications/observation-of-self-organized-frc-formation-in-a-collisio nal-merg 39. Collisional merging formation of a field-reversed configuration in the FAT-CM device | Request PDF - Research Gate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/331514489_Collisional_merging_formation_of_a_field- reversed_configuration_in_the_FAT-CM_device 40. Four-wave mixing - Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four-wave_mixing 41. Four-Wave Mixing and its Applications, http://nathan.instras.com/document DB/paper-52.pdf 42. Resonant four-wave mixing of laser radiation in plasmas - Research Gate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/243578312_Resonant_four-wave_mixing_of_laser_ra diation_in_plasmas 43. Degenerate four-wave mixing mediated by ponderomotive-force-driven plasma gratings | Phys. Rev. E - Physical Review Link Manager, https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phys Rev E.75.036403